Tony Hackworth's men came from behind to grab a dramatic victory on Friday night.
Pikes came close through Nathan Dyer early on and grabbed the lead through George Brown, after skipper Connor Avison's header.
However, visitors Penrith, from the equivalent Northern League, levelled just after the half hour.
The Cumbrians then went in front for the first time with 15 minutes left.
But a beautiful through ball picked out Joe Wood to slot home one on one, with eight minutes remaining.
However, there was even better to come as Pikes won it at the death.
Within ten minutes of his introduction, Jordan Hinds settled the clash with a 93-rd minute winner to book a home clash with another Northern League side in the next round. It'll be Easington Colliery or Boro Rangers at Mill Lane for the Preliminary Round clash.


Farmers And Businesses Await Compensation A Year After Massive Whitby Wildfire
Four Hundred Sandcastles Will Transform Scarborough's South Bay For Anniversary Challenge
Council Reprimanded Over Scarborough Harbour Information 'Failure'
Scarborough Athletic Held To Second Goalless Draw In Four Days
Whitby Town Bounce Back In Style After Barren Run
Updated Adult Gaming Centre Plan for Whitby After Council Refusal
Major Sutton Bank Work Begins
Man Who Drove at Police in Scarborough Jailed
Illuminated Motorcycles And Drones Set To Dazzle Scarborough
Scarborough Pride Returns This Saturday With Its Biggest Parade And Marketplace Yet
'Don’t Blame Pubs for Lack of Public Loos', Council Told Amid 3am Licensing Row
New £1 Billion Battery-Electric Trains to Transform Scarborough Rail Services







Comments
Add a comment